Dear Mary
My Sister – The Thief

|

Please share with your friends: Share on email
Email
Share on linkedin
Linkedin
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on facebook
Facebook

Dear Mary,

I am going out of my mind. We just had our mother’s funeral last week and my sister has started to go into our mother’s house and is taking things out. These are family “things” some of value, most of sentimental value. What should I do?

Brenda

Hi Brenda:

This is a terrible situation. You have just had the emotional rollercoaster of a funeral and now to have to deal with dividing up personal possessions is truly stressful (especially when there is fighting and mistrust).

You have to find a way to talk with your sister. Doing this in person is always the best. Emotions are already raw, and the next couple of conversations may dictate the future direction of your relationship with your sister, perhaps for years.

If you do have a face-to-face conversation with her, try and bring some logic and structure to the conversation. Try and stay on track for the purpose of the meeting. It is highly likely that both of you may say things not directly related to the dividing up of the possessions, which will complicate this already toxic situation. When other issues come into this conversation, it can end up being a bee’s nest.

Ask her calmly some specific questions, such as:

  • What did you take?
  • Why did you take those specific things?
  • Does she have an idea of what your mother’s wishes were about the possessions?

Suggest that the “taking of things must stop”. Tell her how hurtful this is to you. Tell her you want to work with her on dividing them up together. You should also:

  • Try to get her to agree to a plan
  • Find some simple common ground to begin to divide up things
  • Take a video camera or pictures of things and where they are in the house
  • Take your time – if you are not in a rush to clean out the house – take some extra time. It will help with your grieving process.

If you cannot meet face-to-face, then these are conversations that need to happen over the phone. Writing letters and emails are less productive, and can come back to haunt you later. Written words can often be interpreted incorrectly.

If your verbal conversations do not work, it is also highly likely that this will force another level of “communication.” At some point, if the two of you are not communicating and making progress, you will need some help to work things through.

Perhaps you have a mutual friend of a trusted family member who might act as a liaison for this process.

There is of course another option. You could hire a 3rd party to negotiate an arrangement. You might want to think about hiring a person has no history with the family and no emotional or professional stake in any of the possessions or family relationship.

I actually know of one family who could not work through things even with a 3rd party negotiated, so one sibling formally charged the other sibling with theft. The lawyers took over and decided everything. This permanently destroyed their relationship, but it did allow for a more fair distribution of the possession. These siblings are still not talking. Both feel hurt and betrayed. There were no winners in this situation. They lost control and they lost each other – which is very sad. I hope this does not happen to you!

So think carefully about everything you do and say. Plan your words and your actions. Your sister needs to know how important this whole issue is to you, and perhaps will meet you half way. Good luck and let me know how things go.

Mary

Please share with your friends: Share on email
Email
Share on linkedin
Linkedin
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on facebook
Facebook

Caregiving Matters

Mary is a daughter. She also Chairs our charity. Mary has also held Director roles on three other boards, most recently with The Palcare Network of York Region.

One response to “My Sister – The Thief

  1. Hello,
    My sister kidnapped our mother at 6 am in the morning, hid her for four months, no agency could help us, the RCMP found her but refused to reveal her location and finally the court ordered the location of our mother. She had been badly hurt, foul play, and the reason for hiding her was to hide the fact that they tried to do away with her as it was discovered that a large amount of money was missing. While she was kidnapped they tried to evict a brother in the house to grab the property to put a daughter in the house and do it all quickly in hopes our mother would die first. They cleaned out 50 years of belongings and it was left to us to deal with the aftermath: nearly dead mother who was told she was abandoned by three of her children. This nightmare is true and there is more to the story but for starters if you think you are having difficulties just realize that it is the wild wild west, people steal, rob and lie and after the lawyers clean you out and you try to get justice through the courts, you are broke and nothing will bring back your loved one. The Enduring Power of Attorney, Capacity Assessments (Pseudo Science) and Guardianship and Trusteeship Industry is rife with abuse and a lucrative business for lawyers who milk the desperate. It is refreshing to find a blog and an individual who has such good advice. It came too late for me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

5 + 1 =